Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: Only I follows
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:When theft rises, the logical response is to tighten controls and deterrents targeted at the problem, not to punish the entire student body indiscriminately.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:Evaluate for relevance and justice. Security strengthening (I) directly addresses theft. A blanket fine (II) is unfair to non-offenders and undermines trust.
Step-by-Step Solution:
1) I: Install exit scanners, improve monitoring, introduce deposit-based lending for high-value items, and ensure proper check-out procedures—logical and effective.2) II: Collective punishment violates proportionality and may be challenged; it does not distinguish between offenders and compliant users.3) Hence only I follows.Verification / Alternative check:Other targeted measures include awareness drives, blacklisting chronic offenders, and integrating ID cards with transaction logs.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
• Only II / Either / Both: II is unjust; combining it with I does not cure the defect.• Neither: Ignores a clear need for better security.Common Pitfalls:Using collective penalties to compensate losses quickly; such measures erode goodwill and are logically unsound.
Final Answer:Only I follows.
Discussion & Comments