Statement–Assumption — Residents of XYZ Colony agitated over irregular water supply. Assumptions: I) Agitation is the right way to secure better water supply. II) The residents suffer an acute problem of water supply. Choose the implicit.

Question

Solve this multiple-choice question and choose the correct option.

Accepted Answer

Introduction / Context:The statement reports residents agitating due to irregular water. We identify the minimal beliefs that must be true to explain such action. Given Data / Assumptions: There is a real, pressing shortage/irregularity affecting residents. Agitation is one of many possible methods (complaints, legal recourse, media). Concept / Approach:For agitation to occur, a serious problem must exist (II). The belief that agitation is “the right way” (I) is not necessary; people may agitate simply believing it may draw attention, not that it is the uniquely right method. Step-by-Step Solution: 1) Establish necessity of a genuine grievance (II).2) Recognise I as a value judgment, not a required assumption. Verification / Alternative check:Public protests typically arise from acute service failures. Why Other Options Are Wrong:“Only I/Both/Neither” either add an unnecessary normative claim or ignore the obvious grievance. Common Pitfalls:Equating “took action” with “this is the best or only action.” Final Answer:Only assumption II is implicit.

Statement–Assumption — Residents of XYZ Colony agitated over irregular water supply. Assumptions: I) Agitation is the right way to secure better water supply. II) The residents suffer an acute problem of water supply. Choose the implicit assumption(s).

More Questions from Statement and Assumption

Discussion & Comments