Magnetic performance — Evaluate the statement: "The highest-speed magnetic storage is achieved by using a floppy disk."

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Incorrect

Explanation:


Introduction:
Among magnetic storage devices, speed is influenced by rotational velocity, areal density, head technology, and interface bandwidth. Floppy disks, an older removable medium, operate at low rotational speeds and have limited density, yielding modest throughput and long seek times compared to hard disk drives (HDDs) and modern magnetic tape systems. The statement claims floppies are the fastest magnetic storage; we will evaluate this claim.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Floppies use flexible magnetic media with simple read/write heads.
  • HDDs use rigid platters, high RPM, precision heads, and caches.
  • Speed refers to sustained transfer rate and access latency.


Concept / Approach:
Floppy disks typically offer data rates in the tens to hundreds of kilobytes per second and high access latency. HDDs deliver orders-of-magnitude higher throughput (tens to hundreds of megabytes per second) and lower average latency due to faster rotation and advanced controllers. Therefore, the claim is incorrect: floppies are among the slowest magnetic media historically used in personal computing.

Step-by-Step Solution:

Define metric: compare sustained transfer and access time across devices.Observe technology differences: RPM, track density, multi-head designs, caches.Conclude: HDDs far exceed floppy performance; floppies are not highest speed.


Verification / Alternative check:

Typical figures: 3.5-inch floppy ~500 kbit/s raw rate vs HDDs with 100+ MB/s modern sustained rates (technology dependent).


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

Correct: Would invert established performance comparisons.True only for 8-inch floppies: Larger floppies still trail HDD performance by wide margins.Depends on laser alignment: Laser is unrelated to magnetic disk reading.


Common Pitfalls:

Confusing simplicity and portability with speed.Comparing across vastly different eras without normalizing technology generations.


Final Answer:

Incorrect

More Questions from Memory and Storage

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion