Technology comparison — Evaluate the statement: "The main advantage of bipolar (TTL) memories over MOS memories is speed."

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Correct

Explanation:


Introduction:
Historically, semiconductor memories were fabricated in different device technologies, notably bipolar (TTL/ECL families) and metal-oxide-semiconductor (MOS). This question asks whether bipolar memories have speed as their main advantage over MOS. Understanding the speed-power-density trade-offs is central to computer architecture history and embedded design choices.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Bipolar technology includes TTL and especially ECL for very high speed.
  • MOS technology underlies SRAM, DRAM, EPROM/EEPROM, and flash.
  • Comparison concerns typical devices from the same era and process generation.


Concept / Approach:
Bipolar transistors switch faster than MOSFETs of comparable vintage due to stronger transconductance and lower intrinsic capacitances at the operating point, leading to shorter propagation delays. However, bipolar devices consume more static power and offer lower density than MOS. Therefore, the principal advantage of bipolar memories has historically been speed, while MOS wins in density, cost, and power efficiency.

Step-by-Step Solution:

Identify property: speed (access time / cycle time) is typically smaller for bipolar memories.Note counter-properties: power consumption is higher; bits per die are lower.Conclude that speed is indeed the primary advantage attributed to bipolar memory over MOS.


Verification / Alternative check:

Compare historical datasheets: ECL RAMs show sub-10 ns access when contemporary MOS parts are slower; at the cost of power and price.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

Incorrect: Neglects well-documented performance leadership of bipolar devices of the time.True only at cryogenic temperatures: Bipolar speed advantage does not require cryogenic operation.Depends only on word width: Access speed is not determined solely by word width.


Common Pitfalls:

Assuming modern CMOS always wins in speed; at equal nodes, specialized bipolar/ECL historically led.Ignoring that speed came with significant power and cost penalties.


Final Answer:

Correct

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion