In reinforced concrete beams, the total length of a cranked (bent-up) bar that rises through a vertical distance d at a 45° angle, for a beam of effective length L, is taken as which of the following?
-
AL + 0.42 d
-
BL + 2 x 0.42 d
-
CL - 0.42 d
-
DL - 2 x 0.4 d
Answer
Correct Answer: L + 2 x 0.42 d
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Bent-up (cranked) bars are used to control shear near supports and to anchor tension steel efficiently. Estimators need a practical rule to add the extra length contributed by two 45° bends that raise and then return the bar over an effective depth d.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Effective horizontal length of the bar = L.
- Crank rises through vertical d at 45° (and returns similarly).
- Standard detailing approximations are acceptable for bar length calculations.
Concept / Approach:The true inclined length to traverse depth d at 45° is d / sin 45° = d * √2 ≈ 1.414 d. However, as the horizontal projection already counts d (since tan 45° = 1), practical estimation uses an empirical addition of approximately 0.42 d per crank to account for the extra length beyond the horizontal projection, bend curvatures, and allowances.
Step-by-Step Solution:1) Two cranks (up and down) occur: total extra allowance ≈ 2 * 0.42 d = 0.84 d.2) Bar length = horizontal L + crank allowances = L + 0.84 d.3) Hence, adopt L + 2 × 0.42 d per standard estimation practice.
Verification / Alternative check:Comparing with exact geometric surplus (2 * (√2 − 1) d ≈ 0.828 d) shows the 0.84 d allowance is a close, conservative approximation including bend curvature.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- L + 0.42 d: Only accounts for one crank, not two.
- Negative adjustments (options C and D) contradict the added length due to bending.
Common Pitfalls:
- Forgetting to include both up and down crank allowances.
- Omitting extra length for hooks/anchorage where specified separately.
Final Answer:L + 2 x 0.42 d.