As per common Indian Standard practice for domestic water-supply design, the peak (maximum) momentary draw-off per capita per minute is taken as which of the following values for the indicated number of users?
-
A1.80 litres for 5 to 10 users
-
B1.20 litres for 15 users
-
C1.35 litres for 20 users
-
DAll the above.
Answer
Correct Answer: All the above.
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Service pipe and storage sizing for small buildings depends on anticipated peak draw-off rates, expressed as per-capita-per-minute values that vary with the number of simultaneous users. Such tabulated values inform plumbing fixture unit calculations and pipe sizing.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- User groups: 5–10, 15, and 20 persons.
- Peak draw-off per capita per minute values are provided.
- Domestic (residential) context under Indian practice.
Concept / Approach:For smaller groups, the per-capita peak rate is higher (lower diversity), and it decreases as the group size increases (higher diversity). The listed values reflect this: 1.80 L for 5–10 users, 1.20 L for 15 users, and 1.35 L for 20 users (intermediate diversity). All are recognized benchmarks for quick sizing.
Step-by-Step Solution:1) Understand diversity effect: as users increase, individual coincidence factor drops.2) Apply tabulated per-capita peaks to compute total peak demand for the design group.3) Check pipe sizing against velocity and head-loss criteria using the computed peak.
Verification / Alternative check:Cross-check with local water authority handbooks where similar per-capita peaks are suggested for preliminary design.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Each of A–C corresponds to a different group size; since all are standard, the comprehensive choice is correct.
Common Pitfalls:
- Applying per-capita peaks from one group size to another without adjustment.
- Ignoring fixture unit method constraints and maximum allowable pipe velocities.
Final Answer:All the above..