Practical limits of binary-weighted DACs Binary-weighted resistor DACs face real-world constraints. In practice, they are most often limited to which resolution without heroic component tolerances?
-
AR/2R ladder D/A converters
-
B4-bit D/A converters
-
C8-bit D/A converters
-
Dop-amp comparators
Answer
Correct Answer: 4-bit D/A converters
Explanation
Introduction / Context:There are two common DAC implementations: binary-weighted resistor networks and R-2R ladders. Understanding the practical resolution limits of each informs architecture choice for precision and manufacturability.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Binary-weighted DAC requires resistor values in powers of two (R, 2R, 4R, 8R, …).
- Switches and op-amp input errors add to resistor tolerance issues.
- Cost-effective precision for large value ratios is difficult to maintain over temperature and production spread.
Concept / Approach:
As resolution increases, binary-weighted DACs demand resistor ratios over a wide dynamic range, making matching and absolute accuracy increasingly hard. This rapidly becomes impractical beyond a few bits. R-2R ladders solve this by using only two resistor values (R and 2R), enabling higher resolutions with reasonable tolerance and layout.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify scaling: for n bits, largest resistor ratio is 2^(n−1):1.Manufacturing stable, precise ratios across such range is hard for higher n.Therefore, binary-weighted DACs are commonly limited to low resolutions, typically around 4 bits, in practical discrete designs.Verification / Alternative check:
Textbooks and lab practice commonly reserve binary-weighted designs for demonstrations (3–4 bits) and use R-2R ladders for 8–16 bit DACs.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- R/2R ladder is a different architecture, not a “limit.”
- 8-bit binary-weighted is theoretically possible, but impractical with standard tolerances and switch errors.
- Op-amp comparator is not a DAC resolution category.
Common Pitfalls:
- Assuming perfect resistor matching is easy; in practice, tolerances and temperature coefficients dominate error budgets.
Final Answer:
4-bit D/A converters