Statement: At a railway level crossing, a bus collided with a running train; around fifty people died. Courses of Action: I. Immediately suspend the train driver. II. Try the bus driver in court for negligence. III. Ensure that all level crossings are manned by the railways.

Verbal Reasoning Course of Action Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
  • A
    Only II follows
  • B
    Only III follows
  • C
    Both II and III follow
  • D
    All follow
  • E
    Neither I nor II nor III follows

Answer

Correct Answer: Both II and III follow

Explanation

Introduction / Context:Level-crossing crashes often involve failure to heed signals, poor visibility, unmanned gates, or unsafe driving. Appropriate action targets accountability and systemic safety rather than reflex punishment without facts.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • A moving train had right of way on tracks.
  • A bus entered the crossing and collided, causing mass casualties.
  • No evidence in the statement that the train driver violated protocol.

Concept / Approach:Proceedings against the bus driver (II) for prima facie negligence (signal violation, gate breach, overspeed) are warranted, subject to investigation. Independently, improving infrastructure/operations by manning crossings (III) reduces recurrence—guards, barriers, alarms, and better sightlines mitigate human error.

Step-by-Step Solution:1) Open investigation; collect CCTV, data logs, witness accounts.2) If negligence is indicated, file charges against the bus driver (II).3) Prioritize manning/conversion of unmanned crossings and grade separation in long term (III).

Verification / Alternative check:Crash-reduction programs consistently show large risk drops after manning or grade separation; arbitrary suspension of compliant train drivers does not improve safety.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:I (suspend the train driver) lacks basis; punishment must follow facts. D (All) wrongly includes I.

Common Pitfalls:Blame-shifting without evidence; ignoring systemic fixes at hazardous crossings.

Final Answer:Both II and III follow.

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion