Statement:\nHalf of the villagers have their own houses. One-fifth of the villagers cultivate paddy. One-third of the villagers are literate. Four-fifths of the villagers are below twenty-five years of age.\n\nWhich of the following is certainly true?\nI. All villagers who have their own houses are literate.\nII. Some villagers under twenty-five are literate.\nIII. A quarter of the villagers who have their own houses cultivate paddy.\nIV. Half of the villagers who cultivate paddy are literate.

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: Only II

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
We must identify a statement that is certainly true given four proportions. Without overlap data, only deductions forced by the Pigeonhole Principle or obvious subset relations can be made.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Own houses: 1/2 of villagers.
  • Cultivate paddy: 1/5 of villagers.
  • Literate: 1/3 of villagers.
  • Below 25 years: 4/5 of villagers.


Concept / Approach:
Check each claim for inevitability considering maximum/minimum overlaps.


Step-by-Step Solution:

• I (All house-owners are literate): Could be false; at most 1/3 literate but 1/2 own houses, so not all house-owners can be literate.• II (Some under 25 are literate): Under-25 are 4/5; literate are 1/3. Even if all 1/3 literate were among the 4/5 under 25, this is consistent and guarantees at least some literate are under 25. It is impossible to place all literate in the 1/5 above 25 because literate (1/3) > above-25 (1/5). Hence II is certainly true.• III (A quarter of house-owners cultivate paddy): Not forced; overlaps could vary.• IV (Half of paddy cultivators are literate): Not forced; overlaps could vary.


Verification / Alternative check:
Use extreme-case overlap to test certainty; only II survives all placements.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
They assert specific overlaps not guaranteed by totals.


Common Pitfalls:
Assuming proportional overlap without justification.


Final Answer:
Only II.

More Questions from Statement and Conclusion

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion