More Questions from Statement and Assumption

Statement–Assumption — “By 2010, India will be the country with the greatest number of heart patients.” Assumptions: I) It is possible to determine and compare the number of heart patients across countries. II) By 2010, India will be the most populated country in the world. Choose the implicit assumption(s).

Verbal Reasoning Statement and Assumption Difficulty: Easy
Choose an option
  • A
    if only assumption I is implicit.
  • B
    if only assumption II is implicit.
  • C
    if either I or II is implicit.
  • D
    if neither I nor II is implicit.
  • E
    None of these

Answer

Correct Answer: if only assumption I is implicit.

Explanation

Introduction / Context:The prediction ranks India at the top by count of heart patients. To make any cross-country “greatest number” claim, one must assume that the underlying counts are measurable and comparable. Population rank is not strictly necessary for such a medical-burden ranking, because prevalence and risk factors vary.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Claim: India will have the highest count of heart patients by 2010.
  • Assumption I: cross-national counts are obtainable and comparable.
  • Assumption II: India will be the most populated country by 2010.

Concept / Approach:Assumption I is necessary: if we could not determine the numbers reliably, a definitive ranking would be baseless. Assumption II is not required: a country can lead in heart-patient counts without being most populous if disease prevalence is higher; conversely, a most populous country might not lead if prevalence is low. The statement never appeals to population ranking; it appeals to absolute case counts.

Step-by-Step Solution:

1) Translate “greatest number” into a need for cross-country epidemiological comparability (I).2) Show population rank (II) is neither mentioned nor logically necessary.

Verification / Alternative check:Public health comparisons regularly use measured incidence/prevalence databases (registries, surveys) to compare countries; this presupposition matches I, not II.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:“Only II” confuses headcount with population rank; “either” overstates; “neither” ignores the measurability premise; “None of these” would imply both, which is unwarranted.

Common Pitfalls:Assuming demographic dominance is the sole driver of disease burden rankings.

Final Answer:Only Assumption I is implicit.

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion