Statement:\nTwo local passenger trains collided while running in opposite directions on the same track because the signalling system failed for a brief period.\n\nCourses of Action:\nI. The services of the motormen of the trains should be terminated immediately.\nII. The government should immediately constitute a task force to review the functioning of the signalling system.\n\nWhich course(s) of action logically follow(s)?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: Only II follows

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
The stated cause of the collision is signalling failure. Rational courses must be aligned to the identified root cause and should avoid punitive steps against individuals without inquiry.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Event: Head-on/opposite-direction collision on same track.
  • Cause given: Signalling failed briefly.
  • Needs: Root-cause analysis, system audit, fail-safe mechanisms (block working, ATP), SOP review.


Concept / Approach:
Terminate vs. investigate: Termination (I) presumes motorman error despite a systems failure being cited. Systems engineering demands audits and technical remedies first; individual accountability, if any, should follow investigation.


Step-by-Step Solution:

1) I (terminate motormen): Not logically supported when the proximate cause is a signalling failure; premature without inquiry.2) II (constitute task force): Directly targets the system failure—review interlocking, signals, backups, maintenance, training, and incident-response. Logical and necessary.3) Therefore, only II follows.


Verification / Alternative check:
Rail safety practice prioritizes independent investigation, safety recommendations, and corrective actions (hardware redundancy, procedural safeguards).


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

• Only I / Either / Both: Punitive action without evidence conflicts with due process and systems logic.• Neither: Ignores the need to fix signalling.


Common Pitfalls:
Attributing complex failures to frontline staff without systemic review.


Final Answer:
Only II follows.

More Questions from Course of Action

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion