Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: Neither I nor II follows
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:Tragic incidents demand prompt action, but logical courses must reflect investigation, accountability aligned to findings, and proportionate remediation—rather than reflexive punishment or irreversible closures without facts.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:We reject actions that presume guilt or impose extreme sanctions without inquiry. Appropriate immediate steps include medical aid, crowd control, forensic/electrical audit, review of safety drills, and temporary suspension if required pending inquiry.
Step-by-Step Solution:
1) Arrest principal immediately (I): Arrest requires prima facie evidence of culpable negligence or violation. Without an inquiry, immediate arrest is not logically warranted.2) Close the school permanently (II): Permanent closure is disproportionate absent conclusive findings. Corrective measures (wiring overhaul, drills, compliance checks) or temporary closure pending safety clearance are more rational.3) Hence, neither I nor II follows at this stage.Verification / Alternative check:Standard responses: set up an inquiry committee, electrical safety audit, enforce compliance, impose penalties if negligence is established, and implement evacuation training—demonstrating measured, fact-based action.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
• Only I / Only II: Each presupposes conclusions without evidence.• Either / Both: Extreme measures are not justified a priori.Common Pitfalls:Letting outrage substitute for process. Logical action requires facts first, sanctions next.
Final Answer:Neither I nor II follows.
Discussion & Comments