Statement–Argument (Align with All US Policies?): Statement: Should India support all international policies of the USA? Arguments: I) No, many other powerful countries do not support those policies. II) Yes, it is the only way to gain US development funds. Choose which argument is strong.

Verbal Reasoning Statement and Argument Difficulty: Hard
Choose an option
  • A
    if only Argument I is strong
  • B
    if only Argument II is strong
  • C
    if either I or II is strong
  • D
    if neither I nor II is strong
  • E
    None of these

Answer

Correct Answer: if neither I nor II is strong

Explanation

Introduction / Context:Foreign policy choices should follow India’s interests, principles, and multilateral commitments—not mimicry or transactional claims.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Argument I: “Others do not support” is an appeal to popularity/authority elsewhere, not a reason grounded in India’s interests.
  • Argument II: Asserts an “only way” to obtain funds—unsupported and reduces policy to a single incentive.

Concept / Approach:Strong arguments should cite national interest tests (security, economy, values). Neither I nor II does so; each is fallacious (bandwagon; false necessity).

Step-by-Step Solution:Assess I: Non-responsive to India-centric criteria ⇒ weak.Assess II: Overly narrow and unsubstantiated ⇒ weak.

Verification / Alternative check:Real alignment is issue-wise, not blanket; funding flows from multiple channels, not one “only way.”

Why Other Options Are Wrong:Endorsing either would legitimise fallacies; both fail strength tests.

Common Pitfalls:Bandwagon reasoning; reducing strategy to aid.

Final Answer:if neither I nor II is strong.

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion