Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: Neither I nor II follows
Explanation:
Given data
Concept/Approach (avoid unwarranted generalization and biased dismissal)
A valid course must follow from the statement. The statement provides no evidence about outcomes of similar boards elsewhere, nor about universal ineffectiveness.
Step 1: Evaluate Course I
Recommending that all other states form similar boards generalizes beyond the provided context without evidence; the statement does not justify replication.
Step 2: Evaluate Course II
Pre-emptively blocking the board assumes inevitable failure; the statement actually indicates intended benefits, not proven ineffectiveness.
Verification/Alternative
A reasonable follow-up (not among options) would be to allow the board to function and evaluate its performance.
Common pitfalls
Projecting conclusions to other states (hasty generalization) or rejecting the initiative with a blanket negative assumption.
Final Answer
Neither I nor II follows.
Discussion & Comments