Tallest person cannot be fixed: P, Q, T, A, and B have different heights. T is taller than P and B, but shorter than A and Q. P is not the shortest. Who is the tallest?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: Cannot be determined

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
The relations place T below both A and Q, and above P and B. However, there is no comparison between A and Q. With all heights distinct, the tallest must be either A or Q, but we cannot tell which.



Given Data / Assumptions:

  • T > P and T > B.
  • T < A and T < Q.
  • P is not the shortest (so B may be the shortest).
  • All heights are distinct.


Concept / Approach:
Construct consistent orders. Since A and Q are both above T and un-compared with each other, each of the two can be the global maximum in some valid arrangement.


Step-by-Step Illustration:

1) Put B at the bottom (since P is not the shortest).2) Place P above B but below T (as given).3) Place T above P and B.4) A and Q are above T, but no order is specified between them.5) Scenario A: A > Q > T > P > B ⇒ tallest is A.6) Scenario B: Q > A > T > P > B ⇒ tallest is Q.


Verification / Alternative check:
Both scenarios satisfy all statements, proving non-uniqueness.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • A or Q alone: Either could be tallest; not uniquely determined.
  • P or B: Both lie below T explicitly; neither can be tallest.


Common Pitfalls:
Forcing an order between A and Q without evidence.


Final Answer:
Cannot be determined

More Questions from Ranking Test

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion