Temperature sensors — Which device behaves similarly to an RTD (resistance varies with temperature) but exhibits a negative temperature coefficient (resistance decreases as temperature increases)?
-
AStrain gauge
-
BThermistor
-
CNegative-type RTD
-
DThermocouple
-
EHall sensor
Answer
Correct Answer: Thermistor
Explanation
Introduction:Resistive temperature sensors change resistance with temperature. RTDs (often platinum) have a positive temperature coefficient (PTC), while thermistors commonly have a negative temperature coefficient (NTC), making them highly sensitive but nonlinear. Selecting the right sensor requires understanding these characteristics.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- We seek a device similar in principle (resistive sensing) to an RTD.
- Required property: negative temperature coefficient (NTC).
- Focus on common industrial/embedded sensors.
Concept / Approach:
Thermistors are ceramic semiconductor resistors whose resistance falls rapidly with increasing temperature (NTC type). They offer high sensitivity over limited ranges and are well-suited for compensation, inrush limiting, and precise temperature monitoring after linearization. RTDs are metal resistors with near-linear PTC behavior and excellent accuracy over wide ranges.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify property: need NTC behavior.Compare candidates: RTD (PTC), thermistor (NTC), thermocouple (EMF device), strain gauge (measures strain), Hall sensor (magnetic field).Only thermistor matches resistive NTC requirement.Therefore select: Thermistor.Verification / Alternative check:
Datasheets classify NTC thermistors (e.g., 10 kΩ at 25 °C) with beta constants describing resistance-temperature curves, confirming the negative coefficient behavior.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Strain gauge: Measures mechanical strain; temperature sensitivity is secondary.
- Negative-type RTD: Not a standard category; RTDs are PTC by definition.
- Thermocouple: Generates voltage from temperature difference, not resistive sensing.
- Hall sensor: Magnetic sensing, not temperature.
Common Pitfalls:
- Assuming all resistive sensors are PTC; thermistors are typically NTC.
- Ignoring nonlinearity of thermistors, which requires linearization for precision measurement.
Final Answer:
Thermistor