Order of magnitude of Debye temperature for metals What is a typical order-of-magnitude value of the Debye temperature θD for common metals?
-
AAbout 10 K
-
BAbout 200 K
-
CAbout 600 K
-
DAbout 2 K
-
EAbout 10,000 K
Answer
Correct Answer: About 200 K
Explanation
Introduction / Context:The Debye temperature θD characterizes the phonon spectrum cutoff and is a key parameter in low-temperature heat capacity, thermal conductivity, and elastic properties. Knowing its typical scale helps in estimating C_v behavior (T^3 law) and distinguishing material classes.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- “Typical” metals at room temperature and below.
- θD values vary widely across elements (tens to several hundreds of kelvin).
- Order-of-magnitude choice rather than an exact number.
Concept / Approach:
For many common metals, θD lies on the order of 10^2 K. Examples: Pb ~ 105 K, Au ~ 170 K, Cu ~ 343 K, Al ~ 428 K, Fe ~ 470 K. Some light or stiff materials can have even higher values, while heavy, soft metals have lower θD. Thus, “about 200 K” best represents a central order-of-magnitude for metals as a class.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Recall several reference θD values across metals.Identify the common scale: hundreds of kelvin (10^2 K).Select the closest order-of-magnitude option: ~200 K.Verification / Alternative check:
Solid-state tables list θD for many metals in the 100–500 K range; this confirms the 10^2 K scaling.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
10 K or 2 K are too low for metals in general; 600 K can occur (e.g., Be) but is not “typical” for the broad class; 10,000 K is nonphysical for θD.
Common Pitfalls:
Assuming a single θD fits all metals exactly; θD is element-specific and influenced by bonding stiffness and atomic mass.
Final Answer:
About 200 K