Staircase proportioning rule: in stair design, the commonly used comfort relationship between the rise (R) and the going/tread (G) is kept approximately equal to which value?
-
A350
-
B420
-
C450
-
D500
-
E600
Answer
Correct Answer: 600
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Designing comfortable and safe stairs involves proportioning the rise and going so that users can walk naturally. Rules of thumb relate R and G to a target value based on human gait.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Rise R and going G are measured in millimetres.
- Use of standard ergonomic proportions.
- Question expects the widely taught comfort rule.
Concept / Approach:The classic Blondel formula is 2R + G ≈ 600 mm (often within 600–650 mm). This places steps within a comfortable stride range. Other variants like R + G ≈ 450 mm appear, but 2R + G is the most recognized basis for proportioning.
Step-by-Step Solution:Identify the intended ergonomic relationship → Blondel's rule.Select the benchmark value commonly rounded to 600 mm.Therefore, the answer is 600.
Verification / Alternative check:Building codes and handbooks endorse ranges like R between 150–190 mm and G between 250–300 mm, which satisfy 2R + G around 600–640 mm.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- 350/420/450/500 do not represent the standard 2R + G comfort target for most occupancies.
Common Pitfalls:
- Confusing the rule as a product R*G; the common comfort relation uses a sum with 2R.
Final Answer:600