Retaining values in synthesizable VHDL: To remember a value across clock cycles in hardware, where must the value ultimately be stored?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: In a registered signal updated inside a clocked process

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
VHDL can describe both combinational and sequential logic. Remembering a value across time requires state, which in hardware corresponds to storage elements such as flip-flops or latches. The common way to infer such storage in synthesizable VHDL is to update a signal inside a clocked process.



Given Data / Assumptions:

  • We are targeting synthesis, not just simulation.
  • State retention across clock cycles implies flip-flops or equivalent.
  • Clocked processes infer registers when signals are assigned conditionally on a clock edge.


Concept / Approach:
Although variables exist in VHDL, a variable by itself does not create hardware storage unless used within a clocked process in a way that infers a register, and even then the physical storage is ultimately realized by flip-flops on signals. The safe and explicit method is to assign to a signal inside a rising_edge or falling_edge process, which synthesis maps to a register.



Step-by-Step Solution:

Declare a signal representing the state (for example, count).Create a clocked process: if rising_edge(clk) then … end if.Assign next-state to the signal within the clocked process.Synthesis produces a flip-flop that holds the value across cycles.


Verification / Alternative check:
Examine synthesis reports or technology schematics: a clocked process with a signal assignment produces a D flip-flop. Simulation confirms that the value persists across edges, not just within delta cycles.



Why Other Options Are Wrong:

Pure function: Functions are combinational by nature and hold no hardware state.Type declaration: Types define data representations, not storage.Combinational variable: Without a clock, no sequential element is inferred; the value does not persist across cycles in hardware.


Common Pitfalls:
Assuming variables inherently create memory; forgetting reset logic for deterministic startup; unintentionally inferring latches by incomplete combinational assignments.


Final Answer:
In a registered signal updated inside a clocked process

More Questions from Counters

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion