Critical Reasoning — Assumptions Statement: A advises B, “You must learn to refer to a dictionary if you want to become a good writer.” Assumptions to evaluate: I. Only writers refer to the dictionary. II. All writers, good or bad, refer to the.

Question

Solve this multiple-choice question and choose the correct option.

Accepted Answer

Introduction / Context:Many advice statements suggest a helpful practice without asserting anything about exclusivity or universality. Here, dictionary use is recommended as a means to become a good writer. We must test two extreme claims for necessity: “only writers use dictionaries” and “all writers use dictionaries.” Given Data / Assumptions: Advice: Use a dictionary to improve writing quality. Assumption I: Only writers use dictionaries. Assumption II: All writers use dictionaries (universal behavior). Concept / Approach: An implicit assumption must be essential for the advice to make sense. Effectiveness of dictionary use for writing does not require claims about who else (non-writers) uses it nor that all writers do so. Step-by-Step Solution: Assumption I is irrelevant. Non-writers (e.g., students, editors) can use dictionaries too; that does not affect the advice’s validity.Assumption II is also not required. Some good writers may not frequently consult a dictionary; the advice still stands as a recommended path, not a universal law. Verification / Alternative check: The advice remains meaningful even if many non-writers use dictionaries and even if some writers do not. Therefore neither I nor II is necessary. Why Other Options Are Wrong: Picking I, II, Either, or Both introduces unwarranted extremes that the statement never relies on. Common Pitfalls: Mistaking a recommended means for an exclusive or universal condition. Final Answer: Neither I nor II is implicit

Critical Reasoning — Assumptions Statement: A advises B, “You must learn to refer to a dictionary if you want to become a good writer.” Assumptions to evaluate: I. Only writers refer to the dictionary. II. All writers, good or bad, refer to the dictionary.

More Questions from Statement and Assumption

Discussion & Comments