Critical Reasoning — Assumptions Statement: “Job interviews should measure personality characteristics of candidates.” Assumptions to evaluate: I. Performance on the job depends on personality characteristics. II. Personality characteristics can be.

Question

Solve this multiple-choice question and choose the correct option.

Accepted Answer

Introduction / Context:This recommendation concerns what interviews should assess. For the recommendation to be meaningful, two premises must hold: personality matters for job performance, and interviews are a suitable context for assessing it. Without either, the prescription fails. Given Data / Assumptions: Prescription: Measure personality in interviews. Assumption I: Job success depends, at least partly, on personality. Assumption II: Interviews can validly and reliably measure personality traits. Concept / Approach: “Should measure” implies relevance to performance (I) and feasibility of measurement (II). If either fails, the “should” collapses—either it is irrelevant or impractical. Step-by-Step Solution: If I is false, assessing personality is pointless for hiring decisions; thus I is necessary.If II is false, interviews are the wrong tool; the recommendation lacks feasibility; thus II is necessary. Verification / Alternative check: Remove I or II: The policy becomes either irrelevant or unworkable, confirming both are needed. Why Other Options Are Wrong: Only I or only II, Either, Neither: Each misses a crucial leg (relevance or feasibility). Common Pitfalls: Assuming that because something is measurable elsewhere (e.g., psychometrics), interviews automatically suffice without stating feasibility. Final Answer: Both I and II are implicit

Critical Reasoning — Assumptions Statement: “Job interviews should measure personality characteristics of candidates.” Assumptions to evaluate: I. Performance on the job depends on personality characteristics. II. Personality characteristics can be measured during interviews.

More Questions from Statement and Assumption

Discussion & Comments