Media policy in a democracy — should government control all news? Statement: Should all news be controlled by the Government in a democracy? Arguments: I. Yes — variety of news only confuses people. II. No — controlled news loses credibility.

Question

Solve this multiple-choice question and choose the correct option.

Accepted Answer

Introduction / Context:The question addresses press freedom versus government control in a democratic setup. A strong argument must align with democratic principles and practical outcomes for information integrity and public trust. Given Data / Assumptions: I claims diversity confuses citizens. II argues that government-controlled news loses credibility among the public. Democracies value pluralism and independent verification as checks on power. Concept / Approach: Credibility in news depends on independence, transparency, and accountability. Monopolized, state-controlled narratives are prone to bias and erosion of trust. Citizens can process varied information; institutions (public broadcasters, press councils) and media literacy help reduce confusion without censorship. Step-by-Step Solution: Argument I: Asserting that variety “confuses” people is paternalistic and ignores the role of plural media in democracy. Weak.Argument II: Controlled news tends to be distrusted and is vulnerable to propaganda, undermining democratic accountability. Strong. Verification / Alternative check: Historical experience shows that press control typically reduces investigative scrutiny and public confidence, validating II. Why Other Options Are Wrong: Only I / Both / Either / Neither: These fail to recognize that I is weak while II is cogent and relevant. Common Pitfalls: Equating information management with truth; credibility stems from independence, not monopoly. Final Answer: Only argument II is strong

Media policy in a democracy — should government control all news? Statement: Should all news be controlled by the Government in a democracy? Arguments: I. Yes — variety of news only confuses people. II. No — controlled news loses credibility.

More Questions from Statement and Argument

Discussion & Comments