Self-defence training for girls — judo and karate in practice Statement: Should girls learn arts like judo and karate? Arguments: I. Yes — such skills can help them defend themselves from rogues and ruffians. II. No — they will lose their feminine grace.

Introduction / Context:This question tests practical reasoning versus stereotype. It asks whether girls should learn martial arts such as judo and karate. The evaluation hinges on safety benefits versus a claim about “feminine grace.”

Given Data / Assumptions:

• I posits a safety benefit: self-defence skills can deter or counter physical threats.
• II asserts a negative aesthetic impact on “femininity,” a subjective and stereotyped claim.
• No evidence is presented that training reduces grace or health; conversely, martial arts often improve coordination and confidence.

Concept / Approach:

• Strong arguments are grounded in tangible outcomes and public safety considerations.
• Stereotypes or value judgments unrelated to the core objective are weak.

Step-by-Step Solution:

Verification / Alternative check:

Why Other Options Are Wrong:

Common Pitfalls:

Final Answer: