Critical Reasoning — Implicit Assumptions Delegation request: “In my absence, I request you to look after the affairs of our company,” says B to C. Assumptions to evaluate: I. C may not accept B’s request. II. C has the expertise to handle the.

Question

Solve this multiple-choice question and choose the correct option.

Accepted Answer

Introduction / Context:When someone requests another to manage affairs in their absence, what must they believe for the request to be reasonable? We evaluate necessity of the two assumptions. Given Data / Assumptions: Request from B to C to handle company affairs. Assumption I: C might refuse. Assumption II: C is capable and competent to handle the role. Concept / Approach:Issuing a request presupposes that the recipient is able to do the job; otherwise the request is irrational. It does not require any belief that refusal is likely. Step-by-Step Solution: 1) If C lacked expertise, asking C to take charge would be unreasonable. Thus II is a necessary assumption.2) Whether C may not accept is not required; the request can be made even if B expects acceptance. Thus I is not necessary. Verification / Alternative check:Negate II: C cannot handle affairs—the request is nonsensical. Negate I: C will accept—request still makes sense. Hence only II is implicit. Why Other Options Are Wrong: Only I / Either / Neither / Both: They either import an unnecessary doubt about acceptance or omit the essential capability assumption. Common Pitfalls:Confusing possibility of refusal with the logic of making the request. Competence is key; acceptance probability is not required. Final Answer:Only assumption II is implicit

Critical Reasoning — Implicit Assumptions Delegation request: “In my absence, I request you to look after the affairs of our company,” says B to C. Assumptions to evaluate: I. C may not accept B’s request. II. C has the expertise to handle the affairs of the company.

More Questions from Statement and Assumption

Discussion & Comments