Critical Reasoning — Assumptions Employment notice clause: “The company has the right to reject any application without furnishing reasons while shortlisting candidates for interview.” Assumptions under test: I. It is desirable to call only eligible or suitable candidates for interview. II. The company follows impartial practices in all its functions.

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: Only assumption I is implicit

Explanation:

Introduction / Context:An employment notice reserves to the company the discretion to reject applications without giving reasons at the shortlisting stage. We must identify which premise(s) are necessary for such a clause to be present. Typically, shortlisting aims to limit interviews to suitable candidates to save time and resources; however, this clause itself does not prove impartiality.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Clause: Company may reject applications without reasons during screening.
  • Assumption I: Interviewing only eligible/suitable candidates is desirable (hence the need to screen rigorously).
  • Assumption II: The company practices impartiality in all functions.

Concept / Approach:

  • A shortlisting clause presupposes a need to filter applications to those deemed suitable.
  • However, the presence of a discretionary rejection clause does not logically imply impartiality; it could be neutral or even permit subjectivity.

Step-by-Step Solution:

Assess I: If it were not desirable to call only suitable candidates, there would be no reason to screen or reserve discretion. Thus I is implicit.Assess II: The clause neither mentions nor guarantees impartiality; it actually asserts unilateral discretion. Therefore II is not implicit.

Verification / Alternative check:

Remove I: The clause loses operational purpose (screening becomes pointless). Remove II: The clause still stands; impartiality is not a necessary premise.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:

Only II — unsupported by the wording.Either / Neither / Both — each mischaracterizes the logical dependence of the clause.

Common Pitfalls:

Confusing organizational aspirations (impartiality) with operational necessities (shortlisting desirability).

Final Answer:

Only assumption I is implicit

More Questions from Statement and Assumption

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion