Selective agents in intestinal bacteriology: effect of crystal violet and sodium deoxycholate A medium fortified with crystal violet dye and sodium deoxycholate will preferentially allow which group of organisms to grow while inhibiting many competitors?
-
AGram-negative intestinal bacteria
-
BGram-positive intestinal bacteria
-
CAquatic (freshwater) bacteria
-
DNone of these
-
EObligate anaerobes from soil
Answer
Correct Answer: Gram-negative intestinal bacteria
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Enteric bacteriology relies on selective media to recover target organisms from complex specimens. Crystal violet and bile salts (or sodium deoxycholate) are classic inhibitors of Gram-positive bacteria and many nonenteric species. Understanding which organisms are favored by such media is essential for diagnostic workflows.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- The medium contains crystal violet (inhibits many Gram-positive bacteria).
- It also contains sodium deoxycholate (a bile salt that suppresses many Gram-positives and nonenteric Gram-negatives).
- Target group is intestinal Gram-negative rods (Enterobacterales and related).
Concept / Approach:
Crystal violet plus bile salts form the basis of MacConkey-like or deoxycholate agars, which select for Gram-negative enteric bacteria while differentiating lactose fermenters. Gram-positive organisms are largely inhibited; environmental aquatic bacteria not adapted to bile are also suppressed.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Recognize the selective agents: crystal violet and deoxycholate.Associate them with enteric selection: Gram-negative intestinal flora tolerate bile.Conclude that Gram-negative intestinal bacteria will grow best.Verification / Alternative check:
Standard manuals list MacConkey and deoxycholate agars as selective for enteric Gram-negative bacilli, exploiting bile tolerance and dye inhibition.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Gram-positive intestinal bacteria: Inhibited by crystal violet and bile salts.
- Aquatic bacteria: Often sensitive to bile; not the selection target.
- None of these / obligate anaerobes: Anaerobes are usually not recovered on such aerobic, bile-containing media.
Common Pitfalls:
- Assuming crystal violet alone is differential; it is primarily selective.
- Confusing selectivity with lactose fermentation differentiation (which requires lactose and an indicator).
Final Answer:
Gram-negative intestinal bacteria