Home » Logical Reasoning » Analyzing Arguments

Some states are considering laws that prohibit calculator use before sixth grade, while other states insist every middle schooler have a graphing calculator; taken together, this paragraph best supports which conclusion about policy views on calculator use in schools within this country?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: There are at least two distinct opinions about using calculators in schools.

Explanation:


Given data

  • One group of states seeks to prohibit calculators before grade six.
  • Another group insists on graphing calculators for all middle school students.


Concept/Approach (extract the minimal warranted inference)
Infer only what both lines of evidence jointly guarantee: policy positions diverge.


Step 1: Recognize opposing policies
Prohibition vs. requirement shows clear disagreement.


Step 2: Avoid overreach
Nothing is said about learning harm, cost in bulk, or historical involvement of legislators.


Step 3: Select the precise supported statement
"There are at least two opinions" exactly captures the supported conclusion.


Verification/Alternative
Imagining a map: some states restrict, others mandate; hence multiple viewpoints exist.


Common pitfalls
Do not infer outcomes (learning results, pricing) not mentioned in the passage.


Final Answer
There are at least two distinct opinions about using calculators in schools.

← Previous Question Next Question→

More Questions from Analyzing Arguments

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion