Critical reading – growth of healthcare managers vs. physicians Data given: practicing physicians +20% over six years; healthcare managers +600% over the same period. Result: many doctors lost authority over schedules, fees, and treatments. What statement is best supported?
-
Aresent the interference of healthcare managers.
-
Bno longer have adequate training.
-
Ccare a great deal about their patients.
-
Dare less independent than they used to be.
-
Eare making a lot less money than they used to make.
Answer
Correct Answer: are less independent than they used to be.
Explanation
Introduction / Context:This question measures your ability to connect statistics with a stated consequence. The passage links a surge in healthcare managers with physicians losing control over key professional decisions.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Physicians increased ~20%.
- Healthcare managers increased >600%.
- Many doctors lost authority to set schedules, fees, and treatments.
Concept / Approach:“Losing authority” implies reduced independence. Select the option that restates that effect without adding motive or unrelated claims.
Step-by-Step Solution:Identify the explicit effect: loss of control.Map to answer language: “less independent than they used to be.”Eliminate emotive or extraneous claims (resentment, training, patient concern, income).
Verification / Alternative check:If you cannot set your schedule, fees, or treatments, your professional independence has decreased; this is tautologically aligned with the correct choice.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Resentment is not stated.
- Training and compassion are not discussed.
- Income effects are not provided.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing causation details with the supported conclusion; the question asks what is supported, not why it occurred.
Final Answer:are less independent than they used to be.