Compound vs. reverse curves: If two curves have the same radius, how does the length of the common tangent compare between a compound curve and a reverse curve?
-
ACommon tangent of the reverse curve will be more
-
BCommon tangent of the compound curve will be more
-
CBoth will be equal
-
DNone of these
-
ENot applicable
Answer
Correct Answer: Common tangent of the reverse curve will be more
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Understanding curve combinations is essential for geometric design, vehicle maneuvering, and safety. Compound and reverse curves behave differently in terms of tangency and steering demand.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Two curves considered have equal radii.
- Definitions: compound curve = same turning direction, arcs meeting at a common tangent point; reverse curve = opposite turning directions separated by a tangent between arcs.
Concept / Approach:In a compound curve, the arcs meet at a common point without any finite tangent length between them; effectively, the intervening tangent length is zero. In a reverse curve, a nonzero tangent is required between the oppositely curving arcs to allow a change in curvature sign and feasible vehicle path.
Step-by-Step Solution:Identify that a compound curve has zero intervening tangent by definition.Recognize that a reverse curve requires a finite common tangent between opposing curves.Therefore, for equal radii, the reverse curve has the longer common tangent.
Verification / Alternative check:Typical geometric diagrams show back-to-back arcs for compound curves, versus arcs separated by tangent for reverse curves, confirming the conclusion.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Compound curve more/equal: contradicts definitions.
- None: terminology provides clear comparison.
Common Pitfalls:
- Confusing broken-back layouts with compound curves.
- Ignoring the operational disadvantage of short tangents in reverse curves at high speed.
Final Answer:Common tangent of the reverse curve will be more