Determinants of horizontal curve design: Selection and sizing of horizontal curves on highways are governed primarily by which set of parameters?
-
ADesign speed of vehicles
-
BPermissible side-friction on the road surface
-
CPermissible centrifugal ratio (e + f limits)
-
DPermissible maximum superelevation
-
EAll the above
Answer
Correct Answer: All the above
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Horizontal curve design must ensure adequate safety and comfort while accommodating expected operating speeds. The main controls balance vehicle dynamics with pavement friction and cross-slope (superelevation).
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Standard design speed chosen for the facility type.
- Limits on lateral friction factor f.
- Maximum superelevation e set by climate, speed, and standards.
Concept / Approach:The governing relationship is V^2 / (225 * R) = e + f in km/h-based units, linking speed, radius, superelevation, and friction. Hence, given speed, permissible e and f limit how small R can be. All these parameters act together to determine the minimum radius and transition length.
Step-by-Step Solution:Fix design speed from functional classification.Adopt limits for e (e.g., 7%–10%) and f (e.g., 0.10–0.15 for comfort/safety).Compute minimum R satisfying e + f ≥ V^2 / (225 * R).
Verification / Alternative check:Any change in speed, e, or f modifies the minimum radius and transition run-off, confirming that all listed factors govern the design.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Options a–d individually matter, but none alone completely determines the curve without the others.
Common Pitfalls:
- Over-reliance on friction at high speeds; superelevation should carry a larger share of centripetal demand.
- Ignoring climate limits on maximum e in snow/ice regions.
Final Answer:All the above