Inference from a Reported Statement “Hitesh told Mohit that a ghost lived by the peepal tree on the outskirts of the village.” What is the most reasonable inference about Hitesh?
-
APeepal trees grow on the outskirts of the village.
-
BGhosts live on peepal trees.
-
CHitesh perhaps believed in the stories of ghosts.
-
DMohit must be afraid of ghosts.
Answer
Correct Answer: Hitesh perhaps believed in the stories of ghosts.
Explanation
Introduction / Context:This assesses cautious inference from a reported statement. We must avoid asserting facts about the external world that are not evidenced and instead infer what is most plausible about the speaker’s belief state.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Hitesh reported to Mohit that a ghost lived by a specific peepal tree.
- We know nothing else about botany, geography, or the actual existence of ghosts.
- The safe inference concerns Hitesh’s beliefs or susceptibility to such stories.
Concept / Approach:From someone asserting a claim about ghosts at a specific location, a cautious, reasonable inference is that the speaker at least entertains or believes such stories. We cannot leap to claims about Mohit’s feelings, the tree’s distribution, or the ontology of ghosts.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify what the statement reveals: Hitesh attributes habitation to a ghost at a location.Infer minimally about Hitesh: he likely believes or has heard and accepted ghost stories concerning that place.Reject world-claims (trees/ghosts existence patterns) not supported by evidence in the statement.Verification / Alternative check:Even if Hitesh were joking or quoting folklore, the most neutral test-prep inference is that he “perhaps believed in the stories of ghosts.” This uses hedging (“perhaps”) and stays within the epistemic reading of the utterance.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- (a) Botany/geography claim not supported.
- (b) Ontological claim about ghosts is unwarranted.
- (d) Mohit’s fear is unknown and not implied.
Common Pitfalls:Overstating conclusions about objective reality from a single reported statement, or inferring emotions of the listener without cues.
Final Answer:Hitesh perhaps believed in the stories of ghosts.