Statement–Argument — Do thin clothes suit people who are overweight? Arguments: I) Yes; thin clothes cling and make one look less fat. II) No; in thin clothes bulges become more prominent. Determine the strong argument(s).
-
Aif only Argument I is strong
-
Bif only Argument II is strong
-
Cif either I or II is strong
-
Dif neither I nor II is strong
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: if only Argument II is strong
Explanation
Introduction / Context:The statement concerns visual appearance effects of fabric thickness. A strong argument should align with general styling principles rather than counter-intuitive claims without reasoning.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Thin, clingy fabrics tend to reveal contours and bulges.
- Heavier or structured fabrics can smooth lines.
- “Suit” is about perceived appearance, not comfort.
Concept / Approach:Argument I asserts the opposite of common styling guidance: clinginess generally emphasizes shape. Argument II aligns with typical observation—thin/clingy materials can make bulges noticeable—hence stronger.
Step-by-Step Solution:
I: Weak—clinging rarely reduces apparent bulk; it often accentuates it.II: Strong—captures the general effect of thin fabrics on silhouettes.Verification / Alternative check:Styling advice frequently recommends thicker/structured materials for smoothing; this supports II.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Granting strength to I would contradict common evidence; “either” is not correct.
Common Pitfalls:Assuming “thin” equals “slimming” regardless of drape and cling; ignoring fabric behavior.
Final Answer:if only Argument II is strong.