Hydrostatic force on plane areas: The resultant pressure force equals area times the pressure intensity at the centroid under which orientation(s) of the plane surface?
-
AArea is horizontal
-
BArea is vertical
-
CArea is inclined
-
DAll of the above
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: All of the above
Explanation
Introduction / Context:
Hydrostatic pressure varies linearly with depth in a fluid of constant specific weight. For any plane surface submerged in such a fluid, the resultant force is equivalent to the integral of pressure over area. A powerful result simplifies its magnitude to the product of area and pressure at the area centroid, irrespective of orientation.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Incompressible fluid at rest with uniform gamma = rho * g.
- Plane surface fully submerged or exposed to hydrostatic head.
- Neglect surface tension and compressibility effects.
Concept / Approach:
The hydrostatic force on a plane area is F = ∫ p dA = ∫ (gamma * h) dA = gamma * (∫ h dA). By definition of centroid depth h_c, we have ∫ h dA = A * h_c. Thus F = gamma * A * h_c = p_c * A, where p_c is the pressure at the centroid. This holds for horizontal, vertical, or inclined planes; only the center of pressure location changes with orientation.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Express pressure p at each point as gamma * h (depth below free surface).Integrate over area: F = gamma * ∫ h dA.Replace ∫ h dA with A * h_c (definition of centroid depth) to obtain F = p_c * A.Verification / Alternative check:
The line of action (center of pressure) lies below the centroid except for horizontal surfaces; its depth is given by y_cp = I_xc / (A * h_c) + h_c. This confirms orientation affects only where the force acts, not its magnitude formula.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Claiming the formula holds only for a specific orientation contradicts the general derivation.
- “None of these” is false because the relation is universally valid for any plane orientation.
Common Pitfalls:
- Confusing magnitude (F = p_c A) with the location of the resultant (center of pressure), which depends on second moments.
Final Answer:
All of the above