Sharp-crested weirs: To ensure a clean, fully aerated nappe for accurate discharge measurement, the crest (plate) thickness is generally kept less than what fraction of the head over the sill?
-
AOne-half of the head on the sill
-
BTwo-thirds of the head on the sill
-
COne-third of the head on the sill
-
DOne-fourth of the head on the sill
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: One-third of the head on the sill
Explanation
Introduction / Context:
Sharp-crested (thin-plate) weirs require a thin knife-edge crest so that the nappe springs clear and aerates, matching standard discharge calibrations. Excessive crest thickness distorts the flow contraction and invalidates empirical coefficients.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Sharp upstream edge maintained; crest not rounded.
- Free overfall with ventilated nappe below the sheet.
- Head over crest within typical laboratory calibration range.
Concept / Approach:
Guidelines recommend the crest thickness be small compared to the head on the sill (H). A widely accepted rule of thumb is t < H/3, which preserves the thin-plate behavior and minimizes interference with the contracted section at the vena contracta.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify the governing principle: maintain a true sharp edge with negligible thickness effect.Apply the guideline: crest thickness less than one-third of the head H.Ensure aeration of the nappe to avoid submergence corrections.Verification / Alternative check:
Standard references (laboratory practice manuals) specify similar limits; many also recommend that upstream face be vertical and downstream edge beveled to sustain a clean separation.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- One-half or two-thirds of H are too thick and disrupt sharp-crested behavior.
- One-fourth of H is conservative but not the commonly cited threshold (question asks the general limit).
- “None of these” is incorrect because the H/3 guideline is standard.
Common Pitfalls:
- Allowing burrs or rounding at the crest, which alters discharge coefficient more than thickness alone.
Final Answer:
One-third of the head on the sill