Gas hold-up measurement in aerated vessels: If Zf is the height of the aerated (gassy) liquid and Zl is the height of the non-aerated clear liquid, what is the expression for the average fractional gas hold-up H?
-
AH = (Zf − Zl) / Zf
-
BH = Zf / Zl
-
CH = Zf / (Zf * Zl)
-
DH = (Zf + Zl) / Zf
Answer
Correct Answer: H = (Zf − Zl) / Zf
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Gas hold-up quantifies the volumetric fraction of gas in a gas–liquid mixture, directly affecting residence times, interfacial area, and mass transfer. A simple way to estimate hold-up is from the increase in liquid height when gas is introduced into a column or reactor.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Zl: height of the clear (non-gassed) liquid at rest.
- Zf: height of the aerated (foamy/gassy) liquid during gas flow.
- Uniform cross-section; negligible wall wetting corrections.
Concept / Approach:The presence of gas expands the mixture volume. The gas fraction equals the volume increase divided by the total aerated volume. With constant cross-section, volumes are proportional to heights, so H = (Zf − Zl) / Zf.
Step-by-Step Solution:Define H = V_gas / V_total.With constant area A: V_gas = A * (Zf − Zl) and V_total = A * Zf.Therefore, H = [A(Zf − Zl)] / (A Zf) = (Zf − Zl) / Zf.Select this expression from the options.
Verification / Alternative check:Independent measurements (e.g., quick shut-off method) yield similar hold-up values, validating the height-based estimate for many systems.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Zf/Zl or Zf/(Zf*Zl): dimensionally inconsistent and do not represent a fraction between 0 and 1.
(Zf + Zl)/Zf: yields values > 1; not a valid fractional hold-up.
Common Pitfalls:
- Failing to account for foam head; Zf should represent the stable aerated level, not transient foam peaks.
- Using this method for non-uniform cross-sections without correction.
Final Answer:H = (Zf − Zl) / Zf