Mixing Reynolds Number in STRs — With liquid density and viscosity constant, how does the impeller Reynolds number depend on the impeller diameter (Dtank fixed)?
-
AIt varies linearly with the impeller diameter (Re ∝ D).
-
BIt varies with the square root of the impeller diameter (Re ∝ D^0.5).
-
CIt varies with the square of the impeller diameter (Re ∝ D^2).
-
DIt varies with the cube of the impeller diameter (Re ∝ D^3).
-
EIt does not depend on diameter at all (Re ∝ D^0).
Answer
Correct Answer: It varies with the square of the impeller diameter (Re ∝ D^2).
Explanation
Introduction:The impeller Reynolds number in a stirred-tank reactor (STR) classifies the mixing regime and strongly influences power draw, mass transfer, and blending. Knowing the correct geometric dependence is essential for scale-up and for comparing vessels with different impeller sizes.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Reynolds number for mixing is defined as Re = rho * N * D^2 / mu.
- Liquid density rho and viscosity mu are constant.
- Impeller speed N and diameter D are variables of interest.
Concept / Approach:
By definition, Re depends linearly on the rotational speed N and on the square of the impeller diameter D. Holding rho and mu constant, any change in D affects Re through the D^2 term. This quadratic dependence underlies why even modest changes in impeller size can move a system from laminar to transitional or turbulent mixing regimes at a fixed speed.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Start from Re = rho * N * D^2 / mu.Treat rho and mu as constants; analyze Re as a function of D.Re scales as D^2 at fixed N.Therefore, the correct dependence is quadratic in D.Verification / Alternative check:
Dimensional analysis confirms the result. Practical observations show that doubling D at fixed N increases Re fourfold, often shifting the flow regime measurably.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
A suggests linear scaling; B suggests square-root scaling; D suggests cubic scaling; E ignores the explicit D^2 dependence in the definition.
Common Pitfalls:
Confusing the D^2 dependence in Re with the D^5 dependence in impeller power correlations; they arise from different relationships.
Final Answer:
It varies with the square of the impeller diameter (Re ∝ D^2).