Shear strength parameter ranges: What is the usual range of the angle of internal friction (φ) for clays under typical conditions?
-
A0° to 5°
-
B5° to 20°
-
C20° to 30°
-
D30° to 45°
-
E45° to 60°
Answer
Correct Answer: 0° to 5°
Explanation
Introduction / Context:The friction angle φ reflects the frictional component of shear strength. In clays, undrained shear strength is governed primarily by cohesion (apparent) with very low friction angle, whereas effective-stress friction angles for OC clays can be higher under drained conditions. The “usual” small φ is commonly referenced for clays in simple discussions.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Typical natural clays in undrained short-term conditions.
- No cementation or unusual structure.
Concept / Approach:For saturated clays tested undrained (UU), φ_u is near zero, leading to total-stress analyses that use undrained shear strength cu. Under long-term drained conditions, especially for overconsolidated clays, effective φ′ may range higher (20–30°), but “usually” for quick characterization of clays, φ close to zero is cited.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify the context (typical clay behavior): φ close to zero in undrained state.Select the option 0°–5° as the usual range.Verification / Alternative check:UU triaxial tests on saturated clays often yield φ_u ≈ 0°. Effective-stress tests (CD/CU) yield larger φ′ but that is a different context.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Higher ranges correspond to sands or drained OC clays, not the usual undrained characterization of clays.
Common Pitfalls:Failing to distinguish total vs effective stress parameters; applying sand φ values to clays.
Final Answer:0° to 5°