Active earth pressure and failure wedge formation: A failure wedge develops in the backfill behind a retaining wall when the wall primarily moves in which manner?
-
AMoves away from the backfill (active condition)
-
BMoves toward the backfill (passive condition)
-
CSinks vertically without rotation
-
DBalances vertical and horizontal stresses equally at rest
-
ERotates about the top but does not change horizontal stress
Answer
Correct Answer: Moves away from the backfill (active condition)
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Retaining-wall pressures depend on wall movement relative to the soil mass. Active movement reduces lateral stress until a limiting state is reached, mobilizing a distinct failure wedge in the backfill governed by soil strength parameters and wall friction assumptions (Rankine or Coulomb theories).
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Backfill is cohesionless or has known c–φ parameters.
- Wall is free to move sufficiently to mobilize active or passive states.
- Plane-strain conditions apply along the wall alignment.
Concept / Approach:When the wall moves away from the backfill, lateral confinement decreases and shear failure initiates along a plane or wedge surface, forming the active failure wedge. Conversely, moving toward the backfill mobilizes passive resistance with a different wedge orientation and much higher force level. At-rest conditions involve minimal movement and no failure wedge formation.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Consider wall movement directions and corresponding earth-pressure states.Active: wall moves away → lateral stress drops to Ka * σv′ → failure wedge forms.Passive: wall pushes into soil → lateral stress rises to Kp * σv′ → different wedge develops in front of the wall.Verification / Alternative check:Classical Rankine/Coulomb solutions and model tests show distinct wedge geometry activated by wall movement direction and magnitude.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- B: Describes passive condition; wedge forms on the front side and not the stated backfill wedge.
- C/D/E: Do not describe the active mechanism producing a backfill failure wedge.
Common Pitfalls:Assuming at-rest pressure produces a wedge; insufficient wall movement will not mobilize the limiting active state.
Final Answer:Moves away from the backfill (active condition)