Directions: Each of the questions given below consists of a statement and/or a question and two statements numbered I and II given below it. You have to decide whether the data provided in the statement(s) is/are sufficient to answer the question. Read both the statements and Give answer (a) if the data in Statement I alone are sufficient to answer the question, while the data in Statement II alone are not sufficient to answer the question; Give answer (b) if the data in Statement II alone are sufficient to answer the question while the data in statement I alone are not sufficient to answer the question; Give answer (c) if the data either in Statement I or in Statement II alone are sufficient to answer the question; Give answer (d) if the data even in both Statements I and II together are not sufficient to answer the question; Give answer (e) if the data in both Statements I and II together are necessary to answer the question. What is the man's speed in still water? I. The speed of the stream is one-third of the man's speed in still water. II. In a given time, the man can swim twice as far with the stream as he can against it.
Verbal Reasoning
Data Sufficiency
Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
-
Aif the data in Statement I alone are sufficient to answer the question, while the data in Statement II alone are not sufficient to answer the question;
-
Bif the data in Statement II alone are sufficient to answer the question while the data in statement I alone are not sufficient to answer the question;
-
Cif the data either in Statement I or in Statement II alone are sufficient to answer the question;
-
Dif the data even in both Statements I and II together are not sufficient to answer the question;
-
Eif the data in both Statements I and II together are necessary to answer the question.
Answer
Correct Answer: if the data even in both Statements I and II together are not sufficient to answer the question;
Explanation
### Concept & Ratio Limitation
To find an absolute numerical speed, we need at least one real-world measurable value (like actual distance or actual time). Ratios alone can never yield an absolute value.
$$Speed = \frac{Distance}{Time}$$
### Step-by-Step Solution
* Let the man's speed in still water be $u$ and the speed of the stream be $v$.
* From Statement I: We are given $v = \frac{1}{3}u$. This is just a ratio. No absolute speed can be determined.
* From Statement II: Let time be $t$. Downstream distance = $2 \times$ Upstream distance.
* $(u + v)t = 2(u - v)t$
* $u + v = 2u - 2v \Rightarrow u = 3v$.
* Statement II provides the exact same mathematical relationship (ratio) as Statement I.
* Combining Statements I and II: Since both statements merely provide the same ratio and lack any absolute time or distance values, the exact speed cannot be calculated.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
If a Data Sufficiency question asks for a specific value and all statements only provide ratios, fractions, or relative multipliers without any absolute anchoring numbers (like km, hours, km/hr), mark it as insufficient immediately.
### Common Pitfall
A common mistake is assuming that because Statement II looks like it involves distance and time, it can be solved. However, the variables cancel out, leaving only a relative proportion.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **if the data even in both Statements I and II together are not sufficient to answer the question;**.