Directions : Each of the questions given below consists of a question followed by three statements. You have to study the question and the statements and decide which of the statement(s) is/are necessary to answer the question. What is the speed of the train? (Bank P.O., 2008) I. The train crosses a signal pole in 18 seconds. II. The train crosses a platform of equal length in 36 seconds. III. Length of the train is 330 metres.
Verbal Reasoning
Data Sufficiency
Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
-
AI and II only
-
BII and III only
-
CI and III only
-
DIII and either I or II only
-
EAny two of the three
Answer
Correct Answer: III and either I or II only
Explanation
### Concept & Logic
To determine the speed of the train, we can use the formula relating speed, distance, and time. If we have the exact length of the train (Statement III), we can find its speed if we know the time it takes to cover a distance proportional to its length (Statement I or II).
### Step-by-Step Solution
* Let the length of the train be $x$ and its speed be $v$.
* **From Statement I:** Crossing a pole in 18s.
$v = \frac{x}{18}$
* **From Statement II:** Crossing a platform of length $x$ in 36s.
$v = \frac{x + x}{36} = \frac{2x}{36} \Rightarrow v = \frac{x}{18}$
* Statements I and II give identical relationships between $x$ and $v$. They cannot be used together to solve for both variables.
* **From Statement III:** $x = 330$ meters.
* By substituting $x = 330$ into either the equation from Statement I or Statement II, we can calculate the speed $v$. Thus, Statement III is essential, and it must be paired with either I or II.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
When Statement II says the train crosses a platform of equal length, it means the train travels twice its own length. If it travels its own length in 18 seconds (Statement I), it should naturally take 36 seconds to travel twice its length. This immediately tells you Statements I and II are identical clues. Therefore, you need the absolute value from Statement III to solve the problem.
### Common Pitfall
A common error is concluding that I and II alone are sufficient because they look like two different scenarios. Always check if the equations derived from the scenarios simplify to the same relationship.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **III and either I or II only**.