Statement: "The bridge was built at the cost of Rs. 128 crores and even civil bus service is not utilizing it, what a pity to see it grossly underutilized." - A citizen's view on a new flyover linking east and west sides of a suburb. Assumptions: The building of such bridges does not serve any public objective. There has to be some accountability and utility of money spent on public projects.

Verbal Reasoning Statement and Assumption Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
  • A
    Only assumption I is implicit
  • B
    Only assumption II is implicit
  • C
    Neither I nor II is implicit
  • D
    Both I and II are implicit
  • E
    Both I and II are implicit

Answer

Correct Answer: Only assumption II is implicit

Explanation

Given data

  • Citizen: A Rs. 128-crore bridge is grossly underutilized (even the bus service doesn't use it) — a pity.
  • Assumption I: Building such bridges never serves public objectives.
  • Assumption II: There must be accountability and utility for public expenditure.

Concept/ApproachIdentify the belief that must be true to judge underutilization as a 'pity' — a standard of utility/accountability for public spending — not a blanket condemnation of all bridges.

Step-by-step reasoningI: The speaker criticizes this bridge's usage, not all bridges. A universal negative about bridges is not required.II: Calling underutilization a 'pity' presupposes public money should be used effectively and with accountability. Hence II is implicit.

Verification/AlternativeOne can value bridges generally yet lament poor utilization; thus I need not hold.

Common pitfalls

  • Overgeneralizing the critique to all infrastructure projects.

Final AnswerOnly assumption II is implicit.

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion