Urea yield in synthesis can be increased by using excess ammonia and higher pressure/temperature. In practice this is avoided primarily because of which combined drawbacks?
-
Aincreased biuret formation
-
Bhigh corrosion rate
-
Cincreased cost of equipment
-
Dall (a), (b) & (c)
-
Enone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: all (a), (b) & (c)
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Urea manufacture from ammonia and carbon dioxide is equilibrium-limited and sensitive to operating conditions. While excess ammonia and higher pressure/temperature can push conversion, plant designers balance yield against materials, by-product formation, and economics. Understanding these trade-offs is essential in fertiliser process design.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Raising pressure and temperature and using excess NH3 can increase apparent conversion.
- Biuret forms more readily at higher temperature and longer residence.
- Corrosion in the urea carbamate environment is severe and worsens under harsher conditions.
- Higher P/T demands thicker, costlier equipment.
Concept / Approach:Process intensification must consider product quality (biuret limits for agriculture), equipment life (corrosion/embrittlement), and capital/operating costs. The cumulative penalty often outweighs incremental yield gains, so industry uses optimized, not extreme, conditions and employs stripper/recirculation schemes instead of simply forcing equilibrium with P/T and NH3 excess.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Relate higher T to biuret formation: 2 urea → biuret + NH3 (undesirable for seeds).Recognize corrosion intensification in carbamate service; alloy selection becomes expensive.Account for mechanical design: higher P/T → thicker walls, higher CAPEX and energy.Therefore, all three drawbacks apply.Verification / Alternative check:Vendor literature and design handbooks specify biuret limits and corrosion-resistant alloys (e.g., 25-22-2) to manage these risks, confirming the multi-factor constraint.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Any single factor alone understates the practical limitation.
- None of these: contradicted by known issues.
Common Pitfalls:Focusing solely on equilibrium without considering kinetics, corrosion, and specification limits for product biuret.
Final Answer:all (a), (b) & (c)