Fundamental principle of heat transfer: Heat flows from one body to another only when there is a temperature difference between them. State whether this statement is correct.
-
AYes
-
BNo
-
COnly if the bodies are solids
-
DOnly when radiation is absent
-
EOnly in a vacuum
Answer
Correct Answer: Yes
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Understanding when heat transfer occurs is foundational in thermodynamics and heat transfer. Heat is energy in transit due to a temperature difference. This question checks whether the learner recognizes that a temperature gradient is the driving potential for conduction, convection, and radiation.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Two bodies or control regions at different temperatures.
- No work interaction is being considered, only thermal energy transfer.
- Transport may occur by conduction, convection, or radiation.
Concept / Approach:Heat transfer requires a nonzero temperature difference. If temperatures are equal, there is thermal equilibrium and net heat transfer is zero. This holds across all three modes: Fourier's law for conduction, Newton's law of cooling for convection, and the Stefan–Boltzmann relation for radiation all imply a driving potential tied to temperature.
Step-by-Step Solution:Identify thermal states: T_hot and T_cold.Recognize driving potential: Delta T = T_hot - T_cold.If Delta T ≠ 0 → heat flows from higher to lower temperature.If Delta T = 0 → no net heat transfer (thermal equilibrium).
Verification / Alternative check:At equal temperatures, thermodynamic equilibrium implies no spontaneous energy flow. Any microscopic exchanges cancel out to zero net transfer.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- No: contradicts the definition of heat as energy in transit due to temperature difference.
- Only if solids: convection and radiation also require Delta T.
- Only when radiation is absent: radiation also ceases with no temperature difference between surfaces facing each other.
- Only in a vacuum: conduction and convection need matter; radiation needs a temperature difference regardless of medium.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing heat (in transit) with internal energy (a stored property). Equal temperatures mean no net heat transfer even though internal energies may differ.
Final Answer:Yes