Heat exchangers: Compared with parallel flow, a counter-current (counter-flow) heat exchanger can transfer ________ total heat between the same two fluids (all else equal).
-
Aless
-
Bmore
-
Cthe same amount
-
Dzero
-
Eonly latent heat
Answer
Correct Answer: more
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Flow arrangement strongly affects the temperature profiles and the log-mean temperature difference (LMTD) in a heat exchanger. Counter-current flow generally yields higher effectiveness than parallel flow given similar sizes and heat transfer coefficients.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Two-fluid, steady-state heat exchanger.
- Same overall heat transfer coefficient and area for both arrangements.
- No phase change (for simplicity).
Concept / Approach:Total heat transfer rate Q is computed using Q = U * A * LMTDCounter-current flow offers a larger LMTD for the same inlet temperatures, because the temperature difference is maintained more uniformly along the length.
Step-by-Step Solution:Compute LMTD for parallel: DeltaT1_par = Th_in - Tc_in; DeltaT2_par = Th_out - Tc_out.Compute LMTD for counter: DeltaT1_cnt = Th_in - Tc_out; DeltaT2_cnt = Th_out - Tc_in.Typically, LMTD_counter > LMTD_parallel → higher Q for counter-current.
Verification / Alternative check:Effectiveness–NTU relations show higher maximum temperature approach on the cold end for counter-current, enabling greater heat recovery.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Less/same/zero: contradict LMTD and effectiveness analysis.
- Only latent heat: arrangement benefits both sensible and latent applications.
Common Pitfalls:Assuming area or U can compensate equally; in design, counter-current is preferred when feasible for better performance and smaller area.
Final Answer:more