Critical Reasoning — Assumptions Context: “At the All India Commerce Conference, the session ‘Management of Service Sector in India’ surprisingly attracted a large number of participants and received very good media coverage.” Which assumptions are implicit?
-
ANone is implicit
-
BOnly I is implicit
-
CAll are implicit
-
DOnly II and III are implicit
-
EOnly either I or III is implicit
Answer
Correct Answer: Only I is implicit
Explanation
Introduction / Context:The report notes a “surprisingly” large attendance and strong media coverage for a session on service-sector management. We need to find what this surprise presumes.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- I: People were not expecting such an encouraging response for the service sector (hence, the surprise).
- II: The service sector is not managed properly in India.
- III: Media is always very positive towards the service sector.
Concept / Approach:“Surprisingly” signals a mismatch between expectations and outcome, not a claim about sector performance or media behavior in general.
Step-by-Step Solution:1) The element of “surprise” directly implies I. Negating I removes the reason to call the turnout and coverage surprising.2) II is not required. High interest and coverage do not automatically imply poor management; they may reflect relevance or growth.3) III is too sweeping. The sentence speaks of this particular event’s coverage, not the media’s perpetual stance.
Verification / Alternative check:Language cue “surprisingly” is a classic pointer to implicit expectations.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- All / Only II and III / Only either I or III / None: Include unsupported generalizations or omit the clear expectation-based assumption.
Common Pitfalls:Avoid reading causal diagnoses (sector mismanagement) into a mere observation about turnout and coverage.
Final Answer:Only I is implicit