Critical Reasoning – Identify the Implicit Assumption(s) Statement: Due to financial constraints, a management institute will charge a placement fee of Rs. 25,000 from the organisation where each student is placed (to be collected at the time of employment). Assumptions: I. This will increase the demand for the institute’s students. II. The amount collected in this way will serve a useful purpose. III. Organisations may select fewer students in the future.

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: None of these

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
The institute introduces a placement fee charged to hiring organizations, citing financial constraints. We must decide which assumptions are necessary for this policy to make sense. The key is to separate what is merely possible from what must be true.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • New fee: Rs. 25,000 per recruited student, paid by the employer.
  • Assumption I: Demand for students will increase.
  • Assumption II: The collected amount will be purposeful (e.g., ease constraints).
  • Assumption III: Employers may reduce future intake.


Concept / Approach:
The policy exists to relieve financial pressure. It does not presuppose an increase in demand (indeed, a fee could deter demand). Nor must it assume that employers will reduce intake; that is a possible risk, not a necessary belief. The only plausible necessity is that the money collected will actually help the institute meet financial needs. However, since none of the provided answer choices allows “Only II,” we must select the option that correctly reflects the mismatch—namely, “None of these.”


Step-by-Step Solution:

I is not implicit: fees rarely increase demand; the motive is funding, not market expansion.II is the reasonable necessity; otherwise, the policy lacks purpose. (But this specific combination is not offered among answer choices.)III is not implicit: it is a cautionary possibility, not a required premise for adoption.


Verification / Alternative check:

Given the options, the accurate logical position (Only II) is absent. Therefore the correct response among the offered choices is “None of these.”


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

Options including I or III add unwarranted claims about market behavior.“Only II and III” wrongly makes the risk (III) a necessity.


Common Pitfalls:

Assuming institutions always predict positive demand effects; here the stated driver is financial constraint.


Final Answer:
None of these

More Questions from Statement and Assumption

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion