Statement–Assumption (Pronoun Clue About D’s Gender): Statement: “She had the ability to be a very good singer but she could not explore herself in that direction,” A tells B about D. Assumptions: I) D is a male. II) D is a female. III) A and B are close friends.
Correct Answer: Only II is implicit
Introduction / Context:Language cues can signal implicit facts. Here, the pronoun “she” used for D indicates gender without being explicitly stated.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- A speaks about D and consistently uses “she.”
- No information on A and B’s relationship is given.
Concept / Approach:In assumption questions, grammatical references that are necessary to interpret the statement count as implicit facts. Social relationships, unless textually required, are not assumed.
Step-by-Step Solution:I: “D is a male” contradicts the pronoun usage. Not implicit.II: “D is a female” is required to interpret “she.” Implicit.III: Whether A and B are close friends is irrelevant to the content of the remark. Not implicit.
Verification / Alternative check:Pronoun resolution is a commonplace inferential step in natural language understanding; here, “she” cannot coherently refer to a male.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Including I violates grammar; including III introduces an unnecessary social premise.
Common Pitfalls:Over-inferring the social context beyond what the statement requires.
Final Answer:Only II is implicit.