Which statement about sanitary sewers is most universally correct for design and public health protection?
-
ASewers must be of adequate size to avoid overflow under peak conditions
-
BSewers must always flow full under gravity in normal operation
-
CSewers must be laid at least 2–3 m deep in all cases to collect basement flows
-
DAll of the above
-
ESewers should be designed to remain pressurized most of the time
Answer
Correct Answer: Sewers must be of adequate size to avoid overflow under peak conditions
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Sewer design balances hydraulics, public health, and economics. This question focuses on which guidance is broadly applicable across most projects.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- We consider normal gravity sewers (not force mains).
- Statements include size adequacy, flow condition, and burial depth.
Concept / Approach:Adequate sizing to pass peak sanitary flow (plus infiltration/inflow) prevents surcharge and overflows. Gravity sanitary sewers are typically designed to run part full at design peak, not full. Burial depth depends on local topography, frost depth, and service connections—not a universal fixed depth.
Step-by-Step Solution:Assess (a): Adequate sizing is a universal requirement to avoid overflows and backups.Assess (b): Normal operation aims for part-full flow with free surface; full flow indicates potential surcharge.Assess (c): Depth varies project-to-project; 2–3 m is not a universal rule.Hence only (a) is consistently correct.
Verification / Alternative check:Standard manuals specify minimum slopes and capacities to maintain self-cleansing velocities while avoiding surcharge—implying part-full, not full, operation.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- (b) Incorrect: design for full flow is atypical for gravity sewers.
- (c) Incorrect: burial depth is site-specific; sometimes shallower or deeper.
- (d) Incorrect: because (b) and (c) are not universally true.
- (e) Incorrect: pressurized operation is for force mains, not gravity sewers.
Common Pitfalls:Assuming that “full” signals good capacity. In sewers, steady part-full flow with a free surface is desired to allow ventilation and minimize surcharge risk.
Final Answer:Sewers must be of adequate size to avoid overflow under peak conditions.