Hazen’s settling relation in water and wastewater treatment is typically applicable to particles of which size range?
-
ADiameters less than 0.01 mm
-
BDiameters less than 0.05 mm
-
CDiameters less than 0.1 mm
-
DDiameters greater than 0.1 mm
-
EColloidal particles only
Answer
Correct Answer: Diameters greater than 0.1 mm
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Different empirical/analytical laws govern settling velocity depending on particle size and flow regime. Recognizing which law applies is essential for sedimentation basin design.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Hazen’s relation is empirical for larger, non-colloidal particles.
- Stokes’ law applies to very small, laminar-settling particles.
Concept / Approach:Stokes’ law is valid for small particles (Reynolds number for particle settling in laminar regime), commonly for diameters below about 0.1 mm in water. For larger grains (sand-sized), inertial effects increase and Stokes’ assumptions break; empirical relations like Hazen's are used.
Step-by-Step Solution:Classify size → boundary near 0.1 mm for water treatment practice.Hazen’s relation → applicable for particles larger than approximately 0.1 mm.Choose the option reflecting this threshold.
Verification / Alternative check:Design manuals differentiate Stokes (fine) vs. Hazen or Newton regimes (coarser).
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Options (a)–(c) refer to smaller sizes where Stokes is more appropriate.
- (e) Colloidal particles do not follow simple gravity settling; they require coagulation-flocculation.
Common Pitfalls:Using Stokes for coarse sand leads to significant errors because laminar assumptions fail.
Final Answer:Diameters greater than 0.1 mm.