Scale-up design problem (Rushton turbine): A cylindrical bioreactor holds 100,000 L of liquid (100 m^3) and has an aspect ratio of 2:1 (liquid height to tank diameter). Estimate the appropriate impeller diameter for a Rushton turbine using the common rule D_impeller ≈ one-third of tank diameter.
-
A1.3 m
-
B3.3 m
-
C5.3 m
-
D7.3 m
-
E0.6 m
Answer
Correct Answer: 1.3 m
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Estimating impeller diameter is a routine early step in bioreactor specification and scale-up. For Rushton turbines in baffled cylindrical tanks, a common heuristic is D_impeller ≈ 0.33 * D_tank. To use the rule, we must first infer the tank diameter from liquid volume and aspect ratio (height/diameter).
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Liquid volume V = 100,000 L = 100 m^3.
- Aspect ratio AR = H / D_tank = 2 : 1, so H = 2 * D_tank.
- Cylindrical working volume: V = (π * D_tank^2 / 4) * H.
- Standard Rushton diameter rule: D_impeller ≈ D_tank / 3.
Concept / Approach:Compute D_tank from the cylinder volume formula using AR = 2. Then apply the one-third rule to obtain the impeller diameter. Finally, map the numerical result to the closest option.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Write V = (π/4) * D_tank^2 * H. With H = 2 * D_tank, V = (π/4) * D_tank^2 * 2 * D_tank = (π/2) * D_tank^3.Solve for D_tank: D_tank = (2 * V / π)^(1/3).Insert V = 100 m^3: D_tank ≈ (200 / π)^(1/3) ≈ 3.99 m (approximately 4.0 m).Apply the rule: D_impeller ≈ D_tank / 3 ≈ 4.0 / 3 ≈ 1.33 m.Choose the closest option: 1.3 m.Verification / Alternative check:Check volume using D_tank = 4.0 m and H = 8.0 m: V_calc = π/4 * 4.0^2 * 8.0 ≈ 100.5 m^3 (close to 100 m^3; rounding explains the small difference). The rule-of-thumb then yields D_impeller ≈ 1.33 m, consistent with the selected answer.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- 3.3 m and 5.3 m: these are closer to full tank diameter choices, not one-third.
- 7.3 m: exceeds the tank diameter implied by the volume.
- 0.6 m: far below typical one-third sizing; would under-mix.
Common Pitfalls:Forgetting to convert litres to cubic metres; misinterpreting aspect ratio (height-to-diameter vs diameter-to-height); applying the one-third rule before computing D_tank.
Final Answer:1.3 m.